Clive Betts writes in retirement from home

THE ENGLISH-RUN Badger Trust and its pals are wonderful at getting their targeting wrong.

The organisation is run from the Home Counties (home, that is, to the well-fed middle class that is the sounding-board for the Right-wing views that dominate the Daily Mail, a paper that almost totally ignores Wales – very unlike how that paper treats both Scotland and Ireland).

The trust is currently donning its green wellies once again in its renewed fight to halt our Assembly from dealing with the badger menace to the dairying industry.

The trust now claims that the Welsh government has committed “another blunder over badgers”.  What’s the blunder ? Saying that results of a cull of badgers to try and halt bovine TB “could be seen in six months”, whereas earlier a different time scale was given.

Notice the use of the word “could”. Not “would”. In other words, results might be seen within that timescale. Or might not.

Hardly a blunder

Unlike some of the oddities which hide within the anti-badger camp.

The trust claims that it is a “national” organisation. Which nation ? The nation of south-east England ?

The trust’s list of fellow and member organisations includes an “overseas” section. At the top of which is Northern Ireland !  Clearly the Six Counties have gained their freedom at last. Or perhaps East Grinstead, Badger Trust HQ, doesn’t know that the Six Counties are still part of the UK “nation”.

Individuals who wish to protest against Elin Jones’s protection of the farming community are invited to sign a couple of petitions.

One of these is organised by Animal Aid – yet another of these south east of England bleading-heart middle class organisations. The petition supporters are invited to sign protests against  “licensing farmers and landowners to kill more badgers”.

Well, well-healed boyoes, Send as many of those petitions as you like to Cardiff Bay. For the Assembly Government has no such plans. Ms Jones would use Welsh government contractors to do the job. Farmers would be allowed to act only within England.

But how would East Grinstead and Tonbridge know the difference between England and Wales ? Both are surely one country, surely.

One of the petitions is being organised by VIVA – which stands for Vegetarians International Voice for Animals.  They   are asking people not to buy Welsh dairy products until a cull stops.

At which presumably VIVA will re-start buying Welsh dairy products. Well, welcome aboard, vegetarians. Treat yourself to a steak !

The Badger Trust seems in any case to be rather out of date. At the head of its web-site, the organisations says “the Conservative Party has said that if it wins the next election it, too, will kill badgers” to help deal with bovine TB.

Perhaps it hasn’t been reported next in East Grinstead that England and its remaining apendages is now governed by a Conservative Prime Minister. To whit,  one Mr Cameron.

Share
 

BadgersNO DOUBT Lorraine Barrett did not mean it to be taken seriously. The badger-lover had – more or less -  offered her own life for the badger …

With an Assembly session on Elin Jones’s proposed badger-cull in selected areas, it seemed a good chance of asking the party which is historically the farmers’ friend – the Tories – what was their attitude to the cull.

No doubt, no change, Tory leader Nick Bourne replied. Well then, what about Lorraine Barrett’s offer of her life before the badgers …

Oh no, said Mr Bourne, she might be the Labour AM for Cardiff South and Penarth. But we rather like her …

Peter Black, co-signer of the motion attacking the badger-cull, was in pretty light mood when tackled.

Presumably he knew he could never win. But it was worth if for the publicity. And for democracy – challenging government decision you don’t like.

“I have a letter from the NFU alleging I was a vegetarian,” he told me. I’m not; I very much like meat, he added.

By the time the spoke in the chamber, Mr Black corrected himself. The letter hadn’t been from the NFU; it was the FUW which got it wrong!

Share
 

I have been following with interest the continuing saga of the proposed Ceredigion Coastal Path and the extremely costly legal fight put up by Mr Lyn Jenkins of Cardigan Island Coastal Farm Park against the joint might of Ceredigion County Council and the Wales Assembly Government – a sort of modern day David versus Goliath.

Cardigan island farmIn the High Court case of Jenkins versus WAG, the Judge Justice Curran said that no coastal path’s outside edge should be closer than two metres to the cliff edge for essential safety purposes. There are numerous locations where the costal path of West Wales is closer than that to the edge of a cliff (including the newly dedicated path on Mr Jenkins’ farm).

This has opened a whole can of worms. It is of serious concern for the safety of path walkers. It is of very serious concern to the residents of West Wales who as Council Taxpayers may have to pay compensation to those killed and injured in falls from such dangerous paths when the claims for damages and compensation come into their Council. More importantly it is an outright moral disgrace how Ceredigion Council (and now WAG) have relentlessly sought to pursue, harass and destroy Mr Jenkins’ livelihood to create a new path that is breaching serious safety issues.

I’m told that none of the Ceredigion Councillors ever visited the proposed path site nor have they been since. If there are now deaths, then they will have blood on their hands and should be individually surcharged by the families who seek compensation.

It is also of note that elsewhere in the UK, that Coastal Paths are diverted around sensitive business areas like Port Meirion; Tintagel Castle; Penclacwydd and National Trust grounds and Ministry of Defence areas. Many of these diversions are purely to safe guard existing Tourist ventures. Cardigan Island Farm Park brings in a lot of revenue to Cardigan. Many of its thousands of visitors also visit the town and spend money there. We do on our visits from Swansea. We buy food drink and petrol and sometimes gifts in your town when we visit, which is often as we keep a Caravan in West Wales.

Can Cardigan afford to destroy Mr Jenkins’ business spin offs or is it some jealous hate campaign your Councillors are running to destroy one successful local businessman who has dared to criticise them?

Ioan M. Richard, Craigcefnparc, Swansea.

Share
 

The bully-boys – and their possible grave-digging pals – of the Badger Trust have been faced down by Elin Jones and the Assembly government.

The trust has since wound themselves up into a fury because Ms Jones has refused to give the names (and the addresses?) of the TB Technical Advisory Group and Programme Board working on the partial badger cull (following by restocking !) that Wales is planning.

Ms Jones has “slammed the door on open government”, says the trust’s press release.

Well, let’s have a bit of open government from the Badger Trust as well. Does Badger Trust Cymru really exist as an independent organisation? Or is it just a convenient made-up name for branches of a “national” (meaning predominantly-English) organization which are sited within our 22 counties.

We all know why the government won’t give names. It’s not only the grave-diggers – who dug up the recently-buried remains of a relative of a person involved in a totally-legal operation; but they are now serving time – but also their equally-extreme friends, to whom the ends justify any means.

Extreme animal-lovers are unfortunately sometimes extreme human-haters.

Badger Trust staff press officer Trevor Lawson (he’s from the English Midlands) himself went a bit extreme in his press release attacking the Assembly’s refusal to list names. These groups are “apparently packed with pro-cull farmers ad the vets who work for them”.

Well, not for the first time, Mr Lawson has proved so much out of touch with what happens in Wales that he counts as a “colonist”. I have known for some time that among the members of these “secretive bodies ” is the Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals.

Perhaps Mr Lawson and his bosses in the outer-London suburb of East Grinstead should be told that the RSPCA has some slight concerns about the tone of the propaganda the BT is pumping out. Propaganda is the correct word – salient facts are omitted; the issues are simplified, sometimes beyond reason.

Mr Lawson hurls out complaints about “secret” groups. He talks about the Assembly as being a “Kremlin”.  Well, I have a word to you. Your tactics – say something often and loudly enough, and people might believe you – perhaps bear the markings of Unter den Linden.

That’s where Josef Goebbels worked.

As to the Welshness of  Badger Trust Cymru…

There’s no website, apart from the East Grinstead one. BT Cymru do apparently meet occasionally; their most recent meeting was in Knighton – no jokes, please, about the town that’s nearest to England, which is where the station is.

Steve Clark does exist (he’s listed as being able to speak “from Cardiff” but on a mobile, and mobiles can exist anywhere). In fact, he lives in Chepstow.

The rather extreme words – “Kremlin”, demanding an “apology” from the minister, and “how low Elin Jones is prepared to sink” – look very much as if they were not penned by Mr Clark who works in Cardiff – but by Mr Lawson.  No doubt, throwing insults is just part of life in the deeply divided societies of both the Midlands and London’s outer suburbs.

The spokesman’s job used to be done by Mike Sharratt, of Whitland – but he had a minor stroke, although he’s back now answering calls.

The badger cull is the most inflammatory issue currently being dealt with by this government.  England is a rather different country to Wales; as long as the BT continue throwing out English-style propaganda and there is no interest in searching for any kind of compromise or accommodation, we can expect the nastiness to continue.

Fortunately the Welsh police forces are pretty good.

I am told Ms Jones is willing to meet Badger Trust “Cymru” again. What a pity the Chief Vet doesn’t speak Welsh; otherwise the govt side of the table could hold their primary discussion in that language, and help put the other side in their place !

Share
 

Badger-lovers seem determined to turn into an international issue the cull of badgers proposed by Welsh minister Elin Jones in order to curb bovine TB.

If Plaid Cymru tried to play off Cardiff against London in order to gain a political or policy point, you can imagine the rumpus which would result from London unionists and their “rwy’n eisiau bod yn Sais” friends in Wales.

Yet the Badger Trust, the self-pronounced friend of badgers, is playing exactly that line in their current moves to force Wales to follow England and abandon all plans for a cull.

Of course, to the trust, with its bases in Britain’s richest suburbs near London and around the Midlands, it must seem almost an (unadmitted) nationalistic battle. When the English rural ministry (Defra) launched a consultation on the issue about two years ago, the responses came OVERWHELMINGLY from the South East and the South West – England’s areas of opulence, where live the upper middle classes who once ruled the world and now have only Wales to concern themselves with.

Of the total responses, an incredible 24pc came south east England, and 25pc from the south west. The government’s own figures show that a pressure group had been solidly at work – in some English regions, no less than 99pc of responses were opposed to a badger cull.

One must congratulate East Grinstead-based trust on its hard work in its own region.

But, as with all pressure groups, one must examine closely what they say. They always cry out that they base their views of “science”. But “science” is never that simple. Continue reading »

Share
 

The fact that the English have decided not to cull their badgers will make no difference to minister Elin Jones.

Glib comments from the Badger Trust in England and from English newspapers will merely prove that they don’t know what they are talking about.

This is a devolved issue, has been for some time, and preparations are slowly grinding towards action. Continue reading »

Share
 

Elin Jones is swiftly getting a name as the coolest, most able and even quietly funniest Plaid minister in the Welsh government.

Updating the press on the bovine tuberculosis outbreak raging in much of rural Wales, she told of the 100 cattle recently culled from contact with the disease at the Gelli Aur farm college near Llandeilo, she suddenly added, “And a cat’s died, too, in the same outbreak.”

Not bad for a laugh. But it hid a serious corollary. If cats can be infected and die from bTB, so can humans, as she confirmed when asked.

cat and pigeonFew people can now remember the massive TB sanatoria which dotted the countryside before the war; even fewer know the number of inmates who contracted TB from cattle (or more probably their milk).

To most town-folk, bTB is a problem for farmers, and badgers are loveable black-and-white creatures immortalised in children’s stories.

But Ms Jones is a dairying farmer’s daughter, thus producing the toughness in the Assembly’s plans which has put London to shame. And a toughness, too, in her response to criticisms.

Sir Jon Shortridge, Welsh government permanent secretary, had made clear to the press yesterday the care with which the multi-faceted policy had been adopted; the culling will be in only one area, which would be impervious to badgers; and it would be allied to universal cattle testing, plus animal welfare security.

The Badger Trust pressure group has already threatened (but has still to take) legal action for a judicial review. When presented with evidence that the far more powerful (indeed, Middle England en masse personified) National Trust criticised a cull and “would be unlikely to participate”, Ms Jones calmly replied, “They’ve already raised this in correspondence.”

Journalists were angling for a flap, over both this, and over who killed four Pembroke badgers (the Badger Trust immediately blamed “farmers”). How to deal with landowners who do not agree to a cull ? “There are a lot of legal opportunities available to us for disease control purposes for the removal of infected animals,” the minister said.

And the killer of those badgers ? Surely we’d hear a few anti-Badger Trust words ? No; to find the criminals is a job for the police, not a cabinet minister. So there !

Enjoy this video of badgers in Dinefwr Park, Llandeilo. They are TB free! (I hope).

Share
 

Assembly folk reckon the Badger Trust is wasting its time trying to judicially challenge minister Elin Jones over her proposed badger cull in one of the disease hot spots.

A senior Assembly Member closely linked to the issue said, “The government’s position is very soundly based, particularly because a cull would be only one of a number of means to be adopted to try and curb the rapid growth of bovine TB.

“The trust’s aims seems simply to be to put a shot over the bows of Defra, the English ministry. Because the political balance of power is different in England, a legal action might cause English ministers to defer – once again – taking similar action on the other side of Offa’s Dyke.”

In Wales, the badgers can call on only one solid supporter who believes that the creature can do no wrong; that’s Lorraine Barrett, Labour, Cardiff South and Penarth. Even fellow Labour urbanite Irene James (Islwyn) took care to say how good Welsh farmers were before she launched her opposition to a cull.

As Labour is no friend of farmers, that can only mean that elements in that party have at last realised just how strong the farming lobby is in Wales and in particular at the Assembly.

Share

Cambria Books

New publication.
Important contribution to our knowledge of the Arab Spring by Denis Campbell.

Cambria Books

New publication. Entertaining guide to the US Elections by Denis Campbell.
© 2011 CAMBRIA POLITICO Suffusion theme by Sayontan Sinha