The failure by the London press to give any news coverage to Wales at the same time as political power is increasingly being passed to the country amounts to a serious failure of both the democratic and journalistic processes, writes Clive Betts from the National Assembly press gallery.

The issue to which no-one has yet given much serious thought over rectification has been raised yet again in today’s issue of the NUJ monthly The Journalist.

Former BBC hack Hywel Morris, a  union life member, was offered the Daily Mail at half-price for three months. Before he started a sub, he bought a copy. To find that there was in the 110 pages “not a single item of Welsh interest in the news or sports sections”.

Many senior journalists – in Cardiff as well as elsewhere – almost laugh at the point. The former MD of Western Mail totally rejected the point about non-London copy being included in regional editions.

Methinks his refusal to allow ANY comparison with what happens in Scotland – and used to happen, although to a much smaller extent in Wales – betrays an Imperialistic mindset, a belief that England is perfect, and that it shows an anti-Welsh attitude.

Mr Morris wrote in The Journalist, “I concluded that the Daily Mail is completely English, and particularly London-oriented – though in fairness it is probably no worse than other daily newspapers printed in London.”

It’s a pity that more journalists in Wales don’t take the same attitude, rather than quietly accepting what has existed since the demise of the Welsh editions of the Mirror, Express and Herald.

Far too little notice of the press in Wales has been taken by thinkers in this country. Aled Jones had very little to say of the present set-up in Press, Politics and Society, A History of Journalism in Wales.

A very valuable vignette was supplied, however, by John Humphries, ex-Mail editor, in his recent Freedom Fighters - saying basically that the management in Wales is anti-Welsh; or, at least, terrified of anything with which the word “Parliament” can be even remotely associated.

One of the few advances for Welshness in the press was the creation of the Llandudno Daily Post – but that was inaugurated by Trinity Mirror in North West England, not by its branch in Wales (ie Cardiff).

Of course, a  regional approach to the Welsh press  is pretty new and radical.  It is the one adopted in the current issue of the academic magazine Cyfrwng – the Media Wales Journal.

Perhaps Public v Private Service; Trinity Mirror in south Wales is slightly spoiled by its left-wing bias and over-acceptance of the arguments produced by my own union, the NUJ. After all, one of that union’s members was violently critical of my repetition in Cambria of John Humphries’s arguments – until he had heard who was their originator.

But Mr Morris’s main complaint is about the attitude of the English nationalist newspapers. An increasing number of their stories are ridiculously inaccurate for Wales, as the Assembly’s political remit expands.

The sole move in a more healthy direction has been the launch of the south Wales edition of the Metro - which is owned by the Daily Mail.

This free morning is printed in Cardiff (by the Western Mail); and it carries each day a small number of local stories (plus plenty of local ads). About half of the entertainment material is southern Welsh (the other half is West Country).

On the sports pages, Welsh international material replaces the English equivalent found in its English editions.

And on occasions news stories change, too. One morning, the front page lead was about a development at Cardiff Airport. The Bristol edition chose a very different story.

London one day carried a story about that city’s Underground which, I hardly imagine was run in Cardiff (or anywhere else).

Were Metro to run the same amount of political-style content as in the Daily Mail, Wales would be justified in demanding that the paper’s London office (where all the sub-editing is done) editionalise its Welsh pages.

Unfortunately, the Metro is really a lite-paper. It specialises in thin, gossipy-style content. Which means there isn’t much cause to complain.

But only at present. Whenever the Metro prints a story which applies only to England, the Cardiff Bay cabinet should send out a sharp correction. And demand some action.

By all means, print whatever you like. But get the Welsh material right. Particularly as you possess the full ability to do so.

Mr Morris can’t stand the Daily Mail. Let’s make sure that his complaint can’t be made against the Mail-lite.

But that means the Cabinet and the Assembly’s departments will have to be ready and willing to act whenever the Metro transcends.

Share
 

Truly madly dottyHere are some snippets from an article in THE SUNDAY TIMES of May 17, 2009 entitled “John Lewis’s wonderland”. One Daisy Waugh describes “The Welsh home of the ‘never knowingly undersold’ shopkeeper (John Lewis)” now up for sale in the heart of Sir Gaerfyrddin for “the same price as a boring terraced house in southwest London.”

“Poor old Wales. What’s actually wrong with it? Does anyone know? Apart from the unpronounceable road signs, which don’t really matter, and the rainfall, which can’t be much worse than, say, in Bristol, and the slightly irritating devotion to a language only kept alive by government edict and European subsidies – apart from all that, it’s just the same as anywhere else in Britain, isn’t it? Mostly green and pleasant. And a lot dozier than London.

There’s not much we’re allowed to snigger at in polite company any more. And yet somehow fat people and the whole of Wales slipped through the sensitivity net.

It must be one of the reasons why the remarkably lovely and extremely luxurious Upton Hall, seven miles from the county town of Carmarthen, is being offered for sale at such a laughably low price.

Anyway, all this could be yours, dear reader, including 22 acres of landscaped garden, for a mere £1.3m: the same price as a boring terraced house in southwest London.

John Lewis is long dead and buried, but clearly his legacy lives on. Nice house. Amazing price. (Never knowingly undersold.) Just a shame it’s in bloody Waaayells.

The standard attitude of us servile, timid, respectful Welsh folk is to “take it on the chin”, “it’s only a joke”, “rise above it” etc. But just imagine the furore if I ended this piece by telling you that Ms Waugh lives in bloody Ing-gerrrr-land.

But don’t let’s rise above telling this daft little trollop what we feel about her comments about us, our language, and our snigger-worthiness.

I feel certain that Ms Waugh would be keen to hear the response of poor, benighted, ignorant, Welsh people. Her email address is:

daisy.waugh@sunday-times.co.uk

I am also sure that the editor of this most worthy of English organs would be interested to share our thoughts, so copy also:

letters@sunday-times.co.uk and online.editor@timesonline.co.uk



Share
 

Victor BlankA TRIP to Bristol on the day after Sir Victor Blank announced he was resigning as chairman of the complete disaster that is the Lloyds-HBOS merger gave a good chance to look at another of Sir Victor’s bits of handiwork.

For some years, he was chairman of the Trinity Mirror newspaper group which controls so much – surely, too much – of the press in Wales.

The group also controls the Daily Mirror - and it was of course only that newspaper which pundits in London cared anything about.

During his years in charge at Trinity Mirror, that flagship newspaper endured very mixed fortunes. Generally bad ones. Solidly overtaken by Murdoch’s Sun, it could find little to hint that any turn-around might beckon.

Why ? A number of reasons were given. Page Three (lack of, in the case of the Mirror) was one.

But some people pointed to another reason for the failure. Apparently, at the time the comment was made, the Trinity Mirror board contained not a single member who had been a journalist.  In sharp contrast, Mr Murdoch, whatever you think about him, is a journalist to his finger tips.

His period at Trinity Mirror also coincided with the Western Mail’s downward slide in standards, it seems. That down-marketing had been underway for years, largely unremarked except occasionally.

When did the slide start ? What were the factors which sparked it ? As we know so little – Wales seems a country unhappy about delving into the proceedings of boars of public companies –  we may be in our thoughts totally unfair to blame Sir Victor.

But his period in charge coincides at least in part with a major change in the comparison between the newspapers in Cardiff and Bristol.

The Bristol morning, the Western Daily Press, was once even considered for closure. The paper kept going, as a tabloid, but one sometimes wondered how much strength lay behind it.

It used to be very much a lightweight comparison to the Western Mail.  While the Mail often dealt in serious politics – I suppose because it tried to represent a nation – the Press’s main point seemed to be reports of the previous evening’s parish council meetings. For some reason, West Country parishes could be quite inflammatory !

But now the relationship is totally different. The Press is now a lively and a fine and serious newspaper. The parish councils seem to have vanished. The paper seems to  consider its readers to be intelligent.

What has happened ? The paper has been taken over by the Daily Mail group. It even uses the same headline type on page one.

But it’s the Daily Mail with a difference.  The Press gives appropriate prominence to the opposite side to the story – which is hardly a strong point for the Mail.

And the paper’s evening companion – the Evening Post - even managed two pages of appreciation about the singer Paul Robeson, with appropriate emphasis on his membership of the Communist Party, his dogged fighting for the underdog, and his shameful treatment by the United States right-wing authorities.

The Post has also gone up-market and now shames totally Cardiff’s South Wales Echo. The difference can be most obviously discerned from the Bristol paper’s interest in its city’s history. Once upon a time, the Echo was similarly interested, but that sort of intelligence has long gone.

But then, the Bristol papers are owned by a company which understands journalism. The same cannot be said about the papers on this side of the channel.

How much of the blame can we lay on the doorstep of Sir Richard ?  He has been gone from Trinity Mirror for some time. But questions have to be asked of that company. Blame has to be allocated, and the problems affecting the Cardiff papers long pre-date the current advertising problems.

Perhaps one day part of the tale will be told of how the Cardiff press has gone resolutely downhill – at the same time as the city has become incredibly more important – while the Bristol papers have become a credit to journalism.

Share
 

The Assembly report on what to do about the future of journalism in Wales is about to be completed – which was just the time for Prof Bob Franklin, of Cardiff University, to come to address AMs.

The language question is basically excluded from the committee’s purview – because it was a manifesto “commitment”. Therefore, to hear more about a reversal of the ditching of support for a Welsh-language daily you’ll have to wait for the next election.

But Prof Franklin got in some good points about the dumbing down which much of the Welsh-based daily media had been inflicting on us for about the last decade or so.

His weakness arose from the left-wing Guardian-style mindset he brought with him.  True, in election coverage there has been a big drop is number of election stories run in 1987 compared with recent polls.

But is that because of newspapers’ commercial demands (maintaining sales); or because of “journalists’ default assumption  that the election would prove boring to readers” ?

And surely those stories printed focus nowadays far more on national than local concerns because of the parties’ central control of the news-events from London; because of the pre-eminence afforded nice news-pictures for the regional evening news; and the abandonment of any hint of policy discussion, with local candidates never allowed to speak for themselves.

What could the Assembly do about the newspaper press in general ?  Subsidies are given some consideration.  They work and are acceptable in Scandanavia, France and Belgium. But, bearing in mind the claimed good profits earned by publishers such a Western Mail and Echo, their use would have to be carefully regulated.

Perhaps the French and Belgian offer to teenagers (“the largest group of newspaper refuseniks”) of a year’s subscription to their favourite daily (which resulted in striking improvements to newspaper-reading attitudes) could re copied.

But nothing about the London dailies in Wales. Beyond an on-line news agency – which is not much use if there’s no space available to print the stories provided because regional editions have long gone.

But – although unmentioned – one such newspaper does in fact exist. The south Wales edition of Metro does in fact on occasion change news pages regionally.  And the day recently when they led one page with a story about the London underground must surely have been replaced in Wales with something Welsh.

If that didn’t happen and the replacement story was British or English, the paper was failing in its duty (is that because it is almost entirely run from London, and staff there might not have realised where Wales started or ended ?).

But tryng to influence the Metro is at least a starting point. And until the Assembly starts trying to make some difference, it won’t get anywhere, or know how far it could get.

Share
 

Resignation PetitionIt will be interesting to see if  this official Downing Street petition asking Gordon Brown to resign gets many signatures. Methinks all those addresses and signatories will end up somewhere on  MI5′ s list or a Labour List spamming/smearing campaign. Mind you some online petitions take off like wildfire so you never know your luck.

Image Hat tip: Guido Fawkes

UPDATE: Carry on up the Prime Minister petition

Share
 

A nasty jibe at newspapers and broadcasters in Wales from the Constitution Unit of University College, London in their latest Monitor.

The unit is faraway the UK’s premier commentator on the devolution changes we have undergone.

The paragraphs on Wales are written by Prof Richard Wyn Jones and Roger Scully of Aberystwyth university.

To highlight the depth of their concern, they lead with their comments on the media.  They refer to “the country’s immature political media, more comfortable with personalised sensation than serious analysis”.

One example is obvious. The Western Mail failed disastrously over its handling of the issue of Tory leader Nick Bourne’s expenses. How many front-page leads did this generate ? Where was the examination (supposing it to be justified) of the expenses claimed by the husband and wife AM who live in Penarth while representing far-flung parts of the Valleys ?

Continue reading »

Share
 

Hopes that the Assembly would lead the battle against the ITV news service entering on a long-running death spasm seem to be false.

The Assembly last term set up what became an exceedingly effective broadcasting committee which did great work ensuring that Wales gets its rightful treatment in a hideously London-biased news media.

In its report, the committee recommended that a permanent communications committee be established, dealing with broadcasting and “related cultural and creative industries” – including newspapers, one would hope.

But today the Assembly business committee – which meets in private – turned down that recommendation. This means that characters such as Michael Grade, boss of ITV, can lie back in the assurance that Wales will no longer be the bother that he feared when he was interviewed by the committee, cut up into slices, and placed in a frying pan ready for roasting. Continue reading »

Share
 

Excalibur is the name of a sword – a mighty (and probably heavy) bejeweled sword wielded by King Arthur who did his Round Table bit in and around Wales (or so it has been mytholigised). Unfortunately, it is also the code name of the NuLabour attack dog team who in the early days of the reign of King Tony were used mainly against the Tory Press and Media. But they are now back, unmuzzled, online and out of their kennels with political bloggers in their sights.

The UK’s two main parties are frantically developing fresh blog strategies in a battle to dominate the political agenda.
PRWeek can reveal that the Labour Party is exploring plans for an online rapid rebuttal unit, designed to kill off damaging stories circulating in the blogosphere.

Source: PR Week

We at Cambria Politico know where they can stick their rebuttals.

Up their buttals.

Share

Cambria Books

New publication.
Important contribution to our knowledge of the Arab Spring by Denis Campbell.

Cambria Books

New publication. Entertaining guide to the US Elections by Denis Campbell.
© 2011 CAMBRIA POLITICO Suffusion theme by Sayontan Sinha