BadgersNO DOUBT Lorraine Barrett did not mean it to be taken seriously. The badger-lover had – more or less -  offered her own life for the badger …

With an Assembly session on Elin Jones’s proposed badger-cull in selected areas, it seemed a good chance of asking the party which is historically the farmers’ friend – the Tories – what was their attitude to the cull.

No doubt, no change, Tory leader Nick Bourne replied. Well then, what about Lorraine Barrett’s offer of her life before the badgers …

Oh no, said Mr Bourne, she might be the Labour AM for Cardiff South and Penarth. But we rather like her …

Peter Black, co-signer of the motion attacking the badger-cull, was in pretty light mood when tackled.

Presumably he knew he could never win. But it was worth if for the publicity. And for democracy – challenging government decision you don’t like.

“I have a letter from the NFU alleging I was a vegetarian,” he told me. I’m not; I very much like meat, he added.

By the time the spoke in the chamber, Mr Black corrected himself. The letter hadn’t been from the NFU; it was the FUW which got it wrong!

Share
 

Badger-lovers seem determined to turn into an international issue the cull of badgers proposed by Welsh minister Elin Jones in order to curb bovine TB.

If Plaid Cymru tried to play off Cardiff against London in order to gain a political or policy point, you can imagine the rumpus which would result from London unionists and their “rwy’n eisiau bod yn Sais” friends in Wales.

Yet the Badger Trust, the self-pronounced friend of badgers, is playing exactly that line in their current moves to force Wales to follow England and abandon all plans for a cull.

Of course, to the trust, with its bases in Britain’s richest suburbs near London and around the Midlands, it must seem almost an (unadmitted) nationalistic battle. When the English rural ministry (Defra) launched a consultation on the issue about two years ago, the responses came OVERWHELMINGLY from the South East and the South West – England’s areas of opulence, where live the upper middle classes who once ruled the world and now have only Wales to concern themselves with.

Of the total responses, an incredible 24pc came south east England, and 25pc from the south west. The government’s own figures show that a pressure group had been solidly at work – in some English regions, no less than 99pc of responses were opposed to a badger cull.

One must congratulate East Grinstead-based trust on its hard work in its own region.

But, as with all pressure groups, one must examine closely what they say. They always cry out that they base their views of “science”. But “science” is never that simple. Continue reading »

Share
 

When rural affairs minister Elin Jones puts her leg up on a table after a briefing, things are obviously perking up down Cardiff Bay.

But she was just showing off her sensible walking shoes, in response to an earlier query from a female journalist.

Ms Jones is rapidly developing as one of the most confident members of the cabinet. Not because of the leg issue, but because of her ability, confidence, and general humour.

“Thank you for your very interesting series of questions on non-governmental issues,” she said at the close of the weekly press briefing given by a cabinet minister, which she had just hosted.

Usually, the relevant minister attempts to interest us in a very long boring list of his colleagues’ engagements. When Ms Jones mentions no more than a couple, and then beams at us, she is virtually demanding that we ask about Alun Cairns – to which she cheekily responds, “I do not wish to contribute to public discussion.”

She equally cheekily complains there is no picture of her in the Western Mail farming supplement – before welcoming her replacement by a close relative.

And in replying about the effect of the Irish rejection of the Lisbon Treaty on the future of the European Union, she remarked she will be a government representative at the farming Council of Ministers in Luxembourg, where she expected to be in the middle of a host of demonstrations – not against herself, you understand.

She then quietly returned to cabinet business … and showed how she is rapidly tying the largely-English Badger Trust (the friends of bTB) in a knot by talking about her plans to cull badgers, and then of the help she will receive from the RSPCA.

From her comments, it seems Ms Jones is more on top of the problem than are the trust and the badger-lovers.



Share
 

I’m glad to note that the Badger Trust is getting things wrong over the Assembly government’s plans to deal with the epidemic of bovine TB.

The Midlands and Sussex-based trust brazenly boasted in a press release that was headed, ‘”I have NOT decided to cull badgers,” Elin Jones admits in Wales.’

Now, we fully realise that the English may not fully understand what powers the Assembly possesses or how it works – it’s indeed difficult enough for Assembly reporters and AMs.

But there’s another matter to consider, as well. That would involve reading through plenary and committee session reports to see precisely what the minister has decided.

If the organisation’s badger expert who speaks from the Midlands of England was to do that – and then to understand what he has read – he would see that the issue is far more complicated than the trust believes.

It seems as if a lot of the trust’s current membership and legacy income is being wasted on a judicial review which is on its way to being thrown out.

Precisely because no culling decision has yet been made !

If you had given Cambria Politico a ring – and then sent a cheque, because I am a journalistic freelance – I, or many of my friends, could have told you precisely that within minutes of Ms Jones finishing her statement.

The Assembly, its ministers, civil servants and lawyers are not as twp as some organisations in England think we are.

Share
 

Elin Jones is swiftly getting a name as the coolest, most able and even quietly funniest Plaid minister in the Welsh government.

Updating the press on the bovine tuberculosis outbreak raging in much of rural Wales, she told of the 100 cattle recently culled from contact with the disease at the Gelli Aur farm college near Llandeilo, she suddenly added, “And a cat’s died, too, in the same outbreak.”

Not bad for a laugh. But it hid a serious corollary. If cats can be infected and die from bTB, so can humans, as she confirmed when asked.

cat and pigeonFew people can now remember the massive TB sanatoria which dotted the countryside before the war; even fewer know the number of inmates who contracted TB from cattle (or more probably their milk).

To most town-folk, bTB is a problem for farmers, and badgers are loveable black-and-white creatures immortalised in children’s stories.

But Ms Jones is a dairying farmer’s daughter, thus producing the toughness in the Assembly’s plans which has put London to shame. And a toughness, too, in her response to criticisms.

Sir Jon Shortridge, Welsh government permanent secretary, had made clear to the press yesterday the care with which the multi-faceted policy had been adopted; the culling will be in only one area, which would be impervious to badgers; and it would be allied to universal cattle testing, plus animal welfare security.

The Badger Trust pressure group has already threatened (but has still to take) legal action for a judicial review. When presented with evidence that the far more powerful (indeed, Middle England en masse personified) National Trust criticised a cull and “would be unlikely to participate”, Ms Jones calmly replied, “They’ve already raised this in correspondence.”

Journalists were angling for a flap, over both this, and over who killed four Pembroke badgers (the Badger Trust immediately blamed “farmers”). How to deal with landowners who do not agree to a cull ? “There are a lot of legal opportunities available to us for disease control purposes for the removal of infected animals,” the minister said.

And the killer of those badgers ? Surely we’d hear a few anti-Badger Trust words ? No; to find the criminals is a job for the police, not a cabinet minister. So there !

Enjoy this video of badgers in Dinefwr Park, Llandeilo. They are TB free! (I hope).

Share
 

Badger TrustWith the Badger Trust determined to obtain a judicial review of the Assembly Government’s decision to implement a limited rural cull of badgers as part of a panoply of measures to hunt the burgeoning bovine TB epidemic ripping though our countryside, Cardiff is entering new and difficult legal waters.

Apparently, badger-lover sites in England have been festooned with threats to take it out on the Welsh – with talk of boycotts of Welsh food, and so on – because of rural affairs minister Elin Jones’s move.

The Badger Trust and their large number of urban pals – who have usually never been nearer to a field than the inside of a car – are convinced that no worthwhile scientific evidence exists to connect Mr Brock with a disease that is at its most rampant in much of southern Wales.

Since 1999, the number of cattle culled in Wales due to infection has grown by a massive 656 per cent – from 660 to almost 8,000 – while the compensation bill has grown more than 1,000 per cent, rocketing from £1.8m to £30m in 2012 if the current trend continues.

In the past, bovine TB has been frequently transmittable to humans, generally through milk. Pasteurisation has seen the end of that transmission change. But the disease’s rampage through southern Wales and western England is now taking its human toll in other ways, through damaged farming livelihoods, and the mental strain of living on farms “locked down” by an infection.

Only a dozen AMs could be found to try and block Ms Jones’s move. Most of these seem utterly convinced that there is utterly no scientific justification for pouncing on badgers. But what about the Royal Society paper proving that only 16pc of herd infections seem due to cattle-to-cattle transmission (the reason for the outbreak favoured by the Badger Trust) ?

Is it any surprise that badger-lovers never refer to this report – particularly as it also finds that 75pc of outbreaks are due to badgers (together with other minor “local” factors).

The Royal Society report was based on a suite of mathematics completely beyond my O-levels. But it fitted neatly with information given by AMs during this week’s debate about the massive TB reservoir hidden within the badger population – 26pc of badgers tested in Gwent, a hot-spot county, have TB. Throughout Wales, according to Lib Dem farmer Mick Bates, 13pc of badgers are infected, compared with far fewer than one per cent of cattle.

Veterinary civil servants in Cardiff pour scorn on some of the Badger Trust’s claims, such as blaming stocking levels, and stock transfers from distances importing the disease. If the latter were true, how come that “closed” farms, which breed their own stock rather than buy in, are affected ?

The issue is clearly beginning to gain an England-versus-Wales angle. If the English want this, perhaps I can apply mathematics to the Assembly’s vote – which saw opposition restricted to only one LibDem; Independent Trish Law; and 10 from Labour.

But it is not mathematically significant that that 10 Labourites include almost the entire group in the Assembly who are trying to apply the brake to the Assembly’s advance towards greater powers – Huw Lewis (Merthyr), Irene James (Islwyn), Lynne Neagle (Torfaen) and Karen Sinclair (Clwyd South).

Minister Elin Jones is unfazed by the legal row as she chatted while being driven north to an engagement. She is quite pleased that so few voted the other way, and got her officers to issue a release stating, “Our commitment is to pursue vigorously a programme of TB eradication in Wales, and we have announced a comprehensive package of measures to meet that commitment. This includes measures to test all cattle herds across Wales in order to measure the extent of the infection, to remove all sources of infection on farms and to review the compensation system.”

It is the comprehensiveness of the measures that Cardiff lawyers will be resting on to beat the challenge from East Grinstead (where the trust is based) into the ground.

Share

Cambria Books

New publication. Important contribution to our knowledge of the Arab Spring by Denis Campbell.
© 2011 CAMBRIA POLITICO Suffusion theme by Sayontan Sinha